logo

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada, Islamorada

Book with us
Up to 10% cheaper
than on Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From266US$ /night
Check-in
20Apr2025Select date
Check-out
21Apr2025Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Resort

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036

Amara Cay Resort, a 4-star Islamorada hotel, features coastal chic accommodations, stunning ocean views, and a variety of modern amenities. Enjoy activities such as paddleboarding and snorkeling while indulging in onsite dining options at the Tiki Bar and ReelCatch.

Rooms & Amenities

Rooms at Amara Cay Resort include premium bedding with upscale toiletries and private balconies. Options range from oceanfront suites to garden-view rooms, ensuring guests can unwind in a stylish setting.

Dining & Options

Dining options feature the poolside Tiki Bar, serving classic American cuisine and tropical cocktails, and the lobby restaurant, ReelCatch, which boasts fresh fish and Keys-inspired dishes. Guests can also enjoy grab-and-go breakfast bites.

Leisure & Services

Amara Cay offers leisure activities like stand-up paddleboarding and snorkeling through nearby excursions. The resort features a pool, fitness center, and complimentary shuttle service within a four-mile radius, enhancing guests' experience.

Activities & Transportation

The resort is conveniently located near attractions such as the History of Diving Museum (3 miles) and Hurricane Monument (1.5 miles). Guests can utilize the nearby marina for fishing and boating excursions, adding to their island adventure.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
Oceanfront Suite
Max:
6 persons
58 m² 
Bed options:
2 Double beds
Sea view
Balcony
Check Prices
King Room
Max:
3 persons
23 m² 
Bed options:
1 King Size Bed
Sea view
Balcony
Check Prices
King Suite
Max:
6 persons
60 m² 
Bed options:
2 King Size Beds
Sea view
Balcony
Check Prices
Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore available ways to reach your dream destination

City Center
Islamorada 2.4 mi
Bus
Bus stop 5.2 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

General

  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Paid Wi-Fi
  • Paid parking
  • 24-hour reception
  • Express check-in/ -out
  • Pets allowed
  • Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
  • Wheelchair access
  • Security
  • Baggage storage
  • Private beach
  • Elevator
  • Smoke detectors
  • Electric vehicle charging station
  • Key card access

Sports & Fitness

  • Fitness center
  • Diving
  • Snorkeling
  • Cycling
  • Golf course
  • Fishing

Services

  • Free shuttle service
  • Pet amenities available
  • Room service
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry
  • Stores/Commercial services
  • Welcome drink

Dining

  • Restaurant
  • Poolside snack bar
  • Snack bar
  • Special diet menus

Business

  • Meeting/ Banquet facilities
  • Fax/Photocopying

Children

  • Children's menu

Facilities for people with disabilities

  • Toilet for disabled

Spa & Leisure

  • Heated swimming pool
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Beach access
  • Beach umbrellas
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area
  • Leisure/ TV room
  • Pool with view
  • Shallow end

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Garden furniture
  • Tea and coffee facilities

Media

  • AM/FM alarm clock
Show more

Location

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036
Map view
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036
Nearby
U.S. 1 at Mile Marker 78.5 77200 Overseas Highway
Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park
0 ft
Restaurants
Reelburger
600 ft
80001 Overseas Hwy
Galley Girls Cafe
1700 ft
79851 Overseas Hwy Mile marker 79.8
Kev's Cafe
1700 ft
79851 Overseas Hwy

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience
76%
liked the resort and would come back again
7.6/10
Very good
Rooms
7.0
Location
8.8
Service
8.6
Dining
5.2
Guest reviews
7.6/10
based on 9 reviews
4/5 based on 2018 reviews
8.0
8.0/10 based on 607 reviews
#8 of 20 hotels in Islamorada based on Tripadvisor
Henry
United States of America, December  2024
8.0/10

I had a pleasant stay at this hotel with great amenities and stunning views. My room was spacious and stylish, but I had a little trouble with cleanliness during my stay. The location was perfect for beach access and relaxation, but the dining experience was somewhat lacking, especially in terms of service. Overall, it’s a great pick if you want to be close to the beach without breaking the bank.

Rooms
7.0
The room was a good size with tastefully decorated interiors and a nice view of the pool and ocean, although I noticed a few cleanliness issues.
Service
9.0
The service was generally excellent and very friendly, with quick responses to my requests.
Location
10.0
The location was unbeatable with gorgeous views and easy access to water sports and relaxing areas.
Dining
5.0
The dining experience wasn't ideal; it felt a bit overpriced and the service was slow, especially on my last day.
Facilities
8.0
The hotel had great facilities including a nice pool area and several amenities.
John
United States of America, November  2024
7.8/10

The hotel has a great location and clean, modern rooms. I enjoyed the comfortable atmosphere, but I had a few issues with the early morning noise and missing bedding. The staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful, which made up for some minor inconveniences. Overall, I’d love to return, but I’d prefer a different room next time!

Rooms
7.0
The rooms were clean, modern, and comfortable, but my room had no window and had some issues with missing sheets.
Service
9.0
The staff was over the top friendly and helpful, though the instructions about the resort bracelet could have been conveyed better.
Location
9.0
The location is fantastic, right on Alligator Reef with great outdoor spaces for relaxation.
Dining
5.0
The dining experience was average; the French toast and panini were good but the overall food quality felt overpriced.
Facilities
8.0
The resort has nice facilities, including hammocks and a new dock, although they could use better maintenance.
David
United States of America, October  2024
7.2/10

The hotel has a great location right by the beach, which I really enjoyed, and the staff was friendly and helpful throughout my stay. However, the room I stayed in was a bit noisy due to loud music from the pool area, and the dining options were overpriced for the quality. Overall, it's a decent spot, but there are a few areas that could use improvement.

Rooms
6.0
The room was right beside the exit to the pool area, which made it quite loud with music blaring throughout the day and night. It felt a bit worn out, with the desk chair's wicker wrapping coming apart and a chip on the bathroom mirror.
Service
9.0
I found the staff to be very friendly and helpful, especially Miguel the GM and Donna, who assisted us in every way possible.
Location
8.0
The hotel is well maintained and has plenty of seating around the pool and beach areas. The beach bar was great for food and drinks, even though the drink service by the pool felt a little lacking.
Dining
5.0
Dining was not great and felt overpriced for what was offered, especially during breakfast hours, which were pretty strict.
Facilities
8.0
The pool area was massive and nicely furnished, providing a good place to relax.
Rick
United States of America, September  2024
8.2/10

I had a nice stay at the hotel, which was beautifully decorated and super clean, but I did notice some wear and tear in the rooms. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, making my experience more enjoyable. However, the dining options could use some improvement, and I was a bit disappointed with the breakfast schedule. Overall, it was still a decent value for money.

Rooms
7.0
The rooms were minimal yet cute, though a bit more dated than the common areas. They did have a microwave and fridge, which was a plus.
Service
9.0
The staff was very friendly, especially the food and beverage team. They were hardworking and courteous.
Location
8.0
The location looked quite nice, and I appreciated the view looking out towards the sea. It’s perfect for a weekend getaway.
Dining
6.0
Dining starts quite late at 7:30, so don’t expect breakfast earlier than that. The food I tried was great, especially the French toast and the panini.
Facilities
8.0
The hotel had some good amenities, and overall, the facilities were well-maintained.
Ian
United States of America, July  2024
7.6/10

I had a pleasant stay at this hotel, enjoying clean and spacious rooms with a nice ocean view, although the air conditioning could have been quieter. The location was amazing with nearby restaurants and plenty of amenities, but the dining was quite overpriced for what we received. Service was generally friendly, but some staff could be warmer and more helpful, especially regarding the resort bracelet. Overall, it's a great place for families but may not be ideal for a quiet couple's getaway.

Rooms
8.0
The rooms were very spacious, featuring wood flooring and a living room connected to a balcony that offered a lovely ocean view. However, the air conditioning could use improvement as it was a bit noisy.
Service
7.0
Overall, the service was good, with staff members showing a smile and a great attitude. However, the communication about the resort bracelet was not conveyed in the most comforting way, which stressed my kids a bit.
Location
9.0
The location is central, with some great restaurants nearby. The hotel has all the amenities to keep families entertained, though it may not be the best choice for couples looking for a relaxing experience.
Dining
5.0
Dining was quite disappointing; we spent over a hundred dollars for basic breakfast items that didn't justify the price. It's a la carte, but I found it to be overpriced given the quality.
Facilities
9.0
The facilities were nice, featuring a pool, bar area, fire pits, and plenty of lounging spots by the water, which added to the enjoyment of our stay.
Looking for an Exclusive Early Booking Rate?
Grab your exclusive rates today!
Check Rates

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.
Check-in
20Apr2025Select date
Check-out
21Apr2025Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room